Ok, I'll try to clarify it a  little to make sure we're all on the same page. Two players, five tosses. Each person chooses same as the other player each time. Here's how it would break down per toss:

Toss One:  Player 1- Rock   Player 2- Rock

Toss Two:  Player 1- Paper    Player 2- Paper

Toss Three:  Player 1- Rock    Player 2- Rock

Toss Four:  Player 1- Scissor   Player 2- Scissor

Toss Five:  Player 1- Paper   Player 2- Paper

So, what are the odds of that happening? 243:1 or the 59k:1?